There are numerous mattress brands out there, which promise to deliver quality products. It could get really hectic trying to find the one that best suits your needs, and obviously, there is no single brand that can serve for everyone’s needs.
However, there are a few brands which rank high in terms of performance, customer satisfaction and overall reviews while remaining affordable. Among them, three best-seller brands are Zinus, Lucid and Signature Sleep, which are all well known in the mattress industry for having extremely low prices and still offering high-quality mattresses.
Here, we will attempt to compare these mattress brands, and exhibit their pros and cons, in order to help you decide which is best for you.
Read on to know more about the following:
Table Of Contents
Basic features of the three brands (Zinus, Lucid and Signature Sleep)
Zinus
The Company has been around since 1979. It started off as an outdoor company which has now turned into a household name selling innovative sleep products at extremely affordable prices. The mattresses offered by Zinus are made in the state-of-the-art ISO-9001 certified factory in Xiamen, China, while they also have a USA headquarters and distribution centers in San Leandro, California. Zinus sells their CertiPUR-US certified beds globally. You can find all sorts of types of mattresses in their lineup, including innerspring, hybrid, and memory foam.
Zinus Mattress Models:
- Zinus Green Tea Memory Foam Mattress - Uses green tea-infused memory foam that helps absorb moisture and odor for a fresher mattress.
- Zinus Cooling Gel Memory Foam Mattress - The gel-infused memory foam top layer prevents heat buildup and keeps sleepers cool.
- Zinus Hybrid Spring Mattress - Combines individually-wrapped coils with foam layers to provide both bounce and cushioning.
Related Zinus products,
Lucid
Lucid is amongst the most renowned brands in the business of online mattresses since they emerged six years ago. They are manufactured by LinenSpa in China and focus on innovative gel memory foam and latex mattresses, with different thickness sizes, including a super thick 16-inch mattress. Lucid is famous for the cool innovative technology used in their CertiPUR-US approved mattresses, whereas they come at very affordable prices and are naturally hypoallergenic and dust-mite resistant. The TENCEL® blend cover used in these best-selling mattresses regulates temperature to provide an improved breathable sleeping surface. Finally, these mattresses excel in comfort and support, with enhanced pressure relieving properties.
Lucid Mattress Models:
- Lucid Memory Foam Mattress - Lucid's classic all-foam mattress that uses memory foam to closely conform to the body.
- Lucid Latex Hybrid Mattress - Pairs responsive latex foam with pocketed coils for a balance of contouring and support.
- Lucid Bamboo Charcoal Memory Foam Mattress - The bamboo-infused foam has moisture wicking and antibacterial properties.
Related Lucid products,
Signature Sleep
Signature Sleep is a company based in China where the products are manufactured compliant with CentiPUR-US accreditation. These mattresses rose to fame and became known for their exceptional prices considering the value offered. You can get their biggest size mattress for less than $ 500, which is really amazing. The company sells directly to consumers through their online site or retail partners.
Signature Sleep Mattress Models:
- Signature Sleep Memory Foam Mattress - An affordably priced thick memory foam mattress.
- Signature Sleep Hybrid Mattress - An inexpensive hybrid with both memory foam comfort and pocketed coil support.
- Signature Sleep Independently Encased Coil Mattress - Made entirely of individually-wrapped coils to provide bounce.
On the downside, they offer only 1-year limited warranty for their products.
There are three collections in their lineup, which are the Black, Gold and Signature collection. There are also other mattresses catering for special needs like youth and folding beds for guests. The thickness of their mattresses varies between 6-13 inches and their collections include memory foam and spring mattresses, as well as hybrid mattresses.
Bestsellers from each brand (Overview table)
ZINUS GREEN TEA MATTRESS | LUCID 10 INCH MATTRESS | SIGNATURE SLEEP CONTOUR | |
---|---|---|---|
Type of sleeper | For any sleeping position | Back and stomach sleepers | For any sleeping position |
Height | 12” | 10″ | 8″ |
Layers (besides cover) |
|
|
|
Cover | KnittedJacquard Cover | Premium TENCEL® cover | Quality very soft knit fabric cover |
Firmness | Medium | Medium-Firm | Medium |
Price | Check price | Check price | Check price |
Zinus vs Lucid vs Signature Sleep (Overall comparison)
ZINUS GREEN TEA MATTRESS | LUCID 10 INCH MATTRESS | SIGNATURE SLEEP CONTOUR | |
---|---|---|---|
Pros |
|
|
|
Cons |
|
|
|
Ideal for… |
|
|
|
Not great if you… |
|
|
|
Full review | Zinus mattress brand review | Lucid mattress brand review | Signature Sleep brand review |
Zinus vs Lucid vs Signature Sleep (Detailed comparison)
Construction
ZINUS GREEN TEA MATTRESS | LUCID 10 INCH MATTRESS | SIGNATURE SLEEP CONTOUR | |
---|---|---|---|
Top cover | The Knitted jacquard cover is breathable and sturdy. | Lucid features a TENCEL® Lyocell blended cover with moisture wicking technology. This makes for a breathable and durable cover.All Lucid mattresses have a removable cover. | Features a super soft knit fabric cover which is breathable and sturdy. |
Foam layers |
|
|
|
Firmness
ZINUS GREEN TEA MATTRESS | LUCID 10 INCH MATTRESS | SIGNATURE SLEEP CONTOUR | |
---|---|---|---|
Zinus comes in a single medium firmness, which is appropriate for any type of sleeping position you prefer. | Although it appears to be medium-firm, this mattress is reportedly a bit too firm and there are some complaints by users in this respect. | This mattress is of medium firmness and appears to be suitable for any sleeper. |
Support
ZINUS GREEN TEA MATTRESS | LUCID 10 INCH MATTRESS | SIGNATURE SLEEP CONTOUR | |
---|---|---|---|
Construction |
|
|
|
Edge support | Zinus reportedly lacks in edge support, so it is probably not a great idea to use the mattress for sitting on the edge. | Lucid is quite supportive even on the edges of the mattress. You can sit on the edge to tie your shows, without falling off. | Contour 8 offers substantial edge support so you can use it for sitting on the edge or eating. |
Motion transfer
ZINUS GREEN TEA MATTRESS | LUCID 10 INCH MATTRESS | SIGNATURE SLEEP CONTOUR | |
---|---|---|---|
Zinus shows slight motion transfer, so it is perhaps not ideal if you sleep with a partner. | Lucid has minimal motion transfer so your partner and you will sleep undisturbed. | This mattress offers excellent motion isolation and is a winner in this category among the three with its individually wrapped pocketed coils. |
Cooling effect
ZINUS GREEN TEA MATTRESS | LUCID 10 INCH MATTRESS | SIGNATURE SLEEP CONTOUR | |
---|---|---|---|
Zinus sleeps really cool, with its green tea and multilayer foam technology. | Lucid probably wins over the other two in terms of sleeping cool, although it is close to Zinus. Its secret lays in the Tencel cover and the open cell structure with the gel memory foam used, which make for a breathable surface with improved air circulation and regulated temperature. | Signature Sleep will sleep cool thanks to the coils used for its build and the breathable cover. |
Value for money
ZINUS GREEN TEA MATTRESS | LUCID 10 INCH MATTRESS | SIGNATURE SLEEP CONTOUR | |
---|---|---|---|
All three brands offer affordable mattresses. Zinus is really amazingly priced given the materials used for its build. The Zinus MF comes in different sizes and is priced $229 on Amazon at the moment. | Lucid offers great value for its money. There are not many brands out there offering this type of quality for such reasonable prices. The Queen size costs $339.94 on Amazon. | Signature Sleep comes at unbeatable prices really. The Queen size is only $177.74 on Amazon, whereas the other sizes are priced as follows: |
Please Note: The prices you see have been recently updated, but are subject to change due to promotions and other factors. Consequently, we can't guarantee real-time accuracy of the prices. Be aware that costs and product availability may vary over time. Please refer to our Price Disclaimer for more information.
Smell – eco-friendly standards
ZINUS GREEN TEA MATTRESS | LUCID 10 INCH MATTRESS | SIGNATURE SLEEP CONTOUR | |
---|---|---|---|
This mattress has no distinct smell or off-gassing. It features a CertiPUR-US certified memory foam used in its construction and is infused with Green Tea extract and Castor Natural Seed Oil to restrain smells and bacteria. |
|
|
Shipping
ZINUS GREEN TEA MATTRESS | LUCID 10 INCH MATTRESS | SIGNATURE SLEEP CONTOUR | |
---|---|---|---|
Zinus mattresses will ship to your doorstep compressed and rolled in a box, free of charge via FedEx/UPS. | Lucid mattresses arrive free of charge to your location, compressed in a box style package. | These mattresses are rolled and compressed into a tiny vinyl case, so you will receive them conveniently at no cost. |
Trial and warranty/ return policy
ZINUS GREEN TEA MATTRESS | LUCID 10 INCH MATTRESS | SIGNATURE SLEEP CONTOUR | |
---|---|---|---|
Trial period | Zinus offers 30 days of trial for their mattresses, unlike other known brands that offer 100 days. | Lucid, similar to Zinus, offers 30 days of trial for their mattresses. | Unfortunately, Signature Sleep does not offer any trial period for their mattresses. So, you must be certain this is the right mattress for you before buying. |
Warranty | Zinus offers 10 years limited warranty on their product. | Lucid offers a great 25 years warranty on their mattresses. It is a winner in this area. | Signature Sleep offers only 1-year limited warranty for their mattresses, which is probably of their biggest downsides compared to their competitors. |
Final Verdict
Zinus Memory Foam Mattress
- Thickness: 12 inches
- Layers: 3 foam layers
- Firmness: Medium soft
- Materials: Memory foam, polyurethane foam
- Features: Green tea extract added
Lucid Memory Foam Mattress
- Thickness: 12 inches
- Layers: 4 foam layers
- Firmness: Medium firm
- Materials: Memory foam, gel memory foam
- Features: Provides comfortable body contouring
Signature Sleep Memory Foam Mattress
- Thickness: 10 inches
- Layers: 1 layer of memory foam
- Firmness: Medium soft
- Materials: High density memory foam
- Features: Very budget-friendly option
To summarize, Zinus offers more foam layering variety, Lucid provides the best quality construction, and Signature Sleep is the most affordable. All three brands sell their memory foam mattresses compressed online in a box. By removing the pricing details, the focus is on the differences in their materials, layers, and overall features.
The mattress brands compared here, are probably of the most affordable you will find on the market. They offer substantial comfort and support, whereas they seem to sleep cool and comply with all necessary safety and health standards.
Zinus offers perhaps the most eco-friendly mattresses of the three since it also uses green tea in its construction apart from the eco-friendly memory foam used. Their Zinus Memory Foam 12 Inch Green Tea Mattress is one of the best sellers on Amazon, alongside the Signature Sleep Contour 8.
Lucid probably sleeps the coolest of the three mattresses, although they all perform well in this area.
Signature Sleep, on the other hand, offers supportive and comfortable mattresses with plenty of pressure relieving properties and great contouring effect.
In terms of trial and warranty policy, Lucid beats the other two for sure, with its amazing 25 years warranty, even though the trial period is the same as what Zinus offers.
On the contrary, Signature Sleep only offers a 1-year limited warranty and no trial period, which is not really great since you cannot claim a refund and is a risk to an extent, having a product that is backed up so short- term.
All things considered, we would recommend choosing between Zinus and Lucid as your first priority over Signature Sleep, due to the fact that they offer substantially better overall performance if you are on the budget.