Casper Vs Tuft Needle: Which One Would You Go For?

Jack C. Haman
Casper or Tuft & Needle? If you have searched among several and think you might have to choose between Casper and Tuft & Needle, this review will help decide which is best for you.

This evaluation will provide a better understanding of the differences and similarities between these two mattress brands and as such, you will be able to make a swift decision if you’ve already narrowed down your choices to Casper Vs Tuft & Needle. So, sit back and read on as we unveil how the two mattresses compare in terms of qualities and contents.

Casper and Tuft & Needle are both popular bed-in-a-box mattress brands known for high quality, affordable memory foam mattresses. The key difference is that Casper uses traditional memory foam, while Tuft & Needle uses their own proprietary T&N Adaptive foam.

Table Of Contents

Casper Mattress Models:

  • Original Casper - This is Casper's flagship mattress that features a foam construction with a top layer of open-cell foam for cooling and pressure relief, followed by a memory foam layer for contouring, and a base layer of support foam. It has a medium firm feel.
  • Nova Hybrid - Casper's hybrid mattress combines foam layers on top with pocketed coils on the bottom for added support and bounce. The foam provides pressure relief while the coils give lift and airflow. It has a medium firmness.
  • Wave Hybrid - Casper's premium hybrid mattress with advanced cooling features. It has a layer of perforated breathable foam, gel pods for targeted cooling, and contoured foam for ergonomic support. The coils provide bounce and edge support. It is medium-soft.
  • Element - Casper's budget-friendly all foam mattress. It has a simple two layer construction of polyfoam over support foam. This creates basic pressure relief and support at an affordable price point. It is medium firm.

Related Casper Mattress Reviews,

Tuft & Needle Mattress Models:

  • T&N Original - Tuft & Needle's original mattress featuring their proprietary T&N Adaptive foam. This polyfoam is designed to provide pressure relief and support. It has a simple two layer foam construction that provides a balanced, medium firm feel.
  • Mint - Tuft & Needle's premium foam mattress. It has a top comfort layer of T&N Adaptive foam followed by two layers of polyfoam for transitional support and base support. Added foam provides more cushioning and cooling. It is medium firm.
  • Hybrid - Tuft & Needle's hybrid mattress combines T&N Adaptive foam with pocketed coils. The foam offers pressure relief while the coils provide bounce, breathability and edge support. This creates a balanced medium firm feel.

Related Casper Mattress Reviews,

Mattress Toppers for Stomach Sleepers
375,349 Reviews Analyzed
Medium Mattress & Box Spring Sets
4,624 Reviews Analyzed
Mattress for Sciatica
647,904 Reviews Analyzed
Organic Mattress Toppers
216,960 Reviews Analyzed
Mattress for Seniors
710,934 Reviews Analyzed
Mattress for Back Pain
560,206 Reviews Analyzed

Casper Original vs Tuft & Needle Original (Overall comparison)

Comparison Points Casper Original Tuft & Needle Original
Construction 3 layers of memory foam 2 layers of T&N Adaptive foam
Firmness Medium-firm, 6-7/10 Medium-soft, 5-6/10
Feel More bounce from memory foam T&N foam is more contouring
Support Zoned support from layered foam Uniform support foam base
Cooling Airflow from open-cell top foam Runs slightly warmer
Price Mid/higher-tier Very affordable

Casper offers more layered support and cooling while Tuft & Needle provides an affordable, evenly contouring mattress. Choose based on preferences.

  CASPER PURPLE
Pros
  • Durable and sturdy build
  • Plenty of hugging and sinking feel
  • Certified foams used throughout
  • Breathable and softcover
  • Good value for money
Cons
  • Not the best support for overweight people
  • Doesn’t sleep as cool
  • Slight off-gassing
  • Not the best choice for side sleepers
  • Rather expensive compared to similar products of other brands
  • Lack of edge support
  • A bit too firm for petite people
  • Perhaps a bit too firm if you have more than a couple of extra pounds and sleep on your stomach
  • Basic construction
  • Needs a firm foundation
  • Not adequate for side sleepers
  • Requires some time of usage before it gets to the medium firm level
Ideal for…
  • People who sleep cold
  • Anyone who fancies a good sinking into the mattress feel
  • Someone who is of average weight
  • People who prefer a firm mattress
  • Someone or a couple of average weight
  • Back and stomach sleepers
  • People who are on a budget
  • People who tend to sleep hot
 
Not great if you…
  • Sleep on your side
  • Have more than a few extra pounds
  • Are looking for a true “luxury” mattress
  • Don’t want to spend much on your mattress
  • Don’t prefer sinking deep down into the mattress
  • Sleep hot
  • Want to use the mattress for sitting and eating
  • Are a side sleeper
  • Have in mind a “luxury” mattress
  • Prefer innerspring mattresses and feel
  • Prefer a soft, plush feel
Full review Casper mattress review Tuft Needle mattress review

Casper vs Tuft & Needle (Detailed Comparison)

Construction

  CASPER TUFT NEEDLE
Top cover
  • Casper features a two-tone cover with white surface and grey sides. It has a stretchy, breathable and removable fabric which can last as long as you take good care of it.
  • The Tactel cover in the Tuft & Needle is made of a blend of polyester and rayon, which is nice to touch and also it is stretchy enough. It features a zipper so you can easily remove and wash it.
  • The cover holds the STANDARD 100 by OEKO-TEX®.
Foam layers
  • Casper is 9.5 inches thick and consists of 4 layers:
  • Comes with a first layer of 1.5-inch poly foam, a second layer of another 1.5-inch memory foam and a third layer of 1.5-inch support foam for enhanced support.
  • Finally the foundation layer is made of 5 inch support foam
  • This mattress is 10 inches thick, as per industry standards. It features two basic layers of the same material: T&N Adaptive® Foam blended high resilience polyurethane foam which is CertiPUR-US approved.
  • The comfort layer features 2.8lbs of the high-density polyurethane foam, whereas the support layer consists of 1.8lbs of high-density polyurethane foam.

Firmness

  CASPER TUFT NEEDLE
Firmness
  • Casper, like most mattresses, adheres to the trend of a universal feel mattress. This basically means it features a medium-firm firmness, with enough hug when you lay down
  • This mattress comes with a firmer than average thickness, at about 7.5 out of 10 in the firmness scale. You have to make sure therefore that it suits your preferences before ordering.

Support

  CASPER TUFT NEEDLE
Construction
  • This mattress is made to provide with enough hugging and sinking down deep into the mattress is characteristic. This is something to keep in mind if you decide to get Casper. It is overall quite supportive.
  • This is probably one of the most supportive mattresses out there. The basic layers of   T&N Adaptive® Foam provide with plenty of support and contour to the body’s natural curves.
Edge Support
  • It seems that the Casper lacks in terms of edge support, which is probably why you shouldn’t prefer it if you consider using the mattress for sitting or other activities during the day.
  • Tuft & Needle provides with better than average edge support and is recommended over Casper if you intend to use your mattress for sitting or eating by the side of the bed.

Motion transfer

  CASPER TUFT NEEDLE
Motion transfer
  • The Casper does a really good job at motion isolation. You can sleep undisturbed even if your partner usually tosses and turns.
  • The Tuft & Needle is probably the better of the two mattresses in terms of providing motion isolation.
  • This is due to the special foam used, similar to latex acting with a localized bounce technology used to manufacture the mattress. You can sleep with a partner and since none of the turns and toss around, which means you get plenty of rest

Cooling effect

  CASPER TUFT NEEDLE
Sleep cool
  • While the Casper sleeps cool in general, due to the more sinking down into the mattress effect, it is best suited for people who tend to sleep cold.
  • The Tuft & Needle is designed to offer a cool sleep, with its breathable structure and enhanced air circulation. It comes with a wicking heat technology which doesn’t leave anybody heat trapped in the mattress.
  • The different layers ensure for a natural airflow that is far better than what most mattress brands have to offer

Value for money

  CASPER TUFT NEEDLE
Price
  • Casper is rather expensive for what it has to offer at $950 for a Queen, especially compared to Tuft & Needle which is far cheaper.
  • Twin size $550
  • Full size $800
  • Queen size $950
  • King/Cal sizes $1,150
  • This is definitely an area where the Tuft & Needle wins over its competitors, including Casper. For the high quality you get, this mattress comes at a low cost and $200 less than Casper. Great value for money and no doubt on which of two is a better bargain if you are on a budget.
  • Twin $400
  • Twin XL $450
  • Full $600
  • Queen $750
  • King/Cal King $900

Please Note: The prices you see have been recently updated, but are subject to change due to promotions and other factors. Consequently, we can't guarantee real-time accuracy of the prices. Be aware that costs and product availability may vary over time. Please refer to our Price Disclaimer for more information.

Smell – eco-friendly standards

  CASPER TUFT NEEDLE
Eco-friendly
  • The Casper comes with CertiPUR-US approved foams, which however appear to give off a distinct smell upon unpacking. Still, the slight off-gassing is safe for your health and dissipated rather quickly
  • You will be glad to hear that the Tuft & Needle reportedly has no off-gassing and distinct smell upon unpacking. In fact, it has been claimed by consumers that this mattress gives off a pleasant smell when out of the box.
  • In any case, the mattress fulfills all national standards for safety and health, as it is CertiPUR-US approved and has won also a GREENGUARD Gold Certification.

Shipping

  CASPER TUFT NEEDLE
Shipping
  • Delivery of Casper is free of charge to all contiguous United States. Your new mattress will arrive compressed in a box style. White glove delivery is available for some areas in LA, SF, Chicago and NYC.
  • This mattress arrives via free shipping in any area of the contiguous United States. Your item will arrive compressed in a small box within 2-5 business from purchase.

Trial and warranty/ return policy

  CASPER TUFT NEEDLE
Trial period
  • You have 100 night trial period to decide if this mattress is suitable for you. If not, Casper will arrange to pick it up for free and donate it to charity or have it recycled by a third partner.
  • Exactly the same as Casper, Tuft & Needle offers 100 night trial period, during which you can decide if this mattress is the right pick for you. If not, you can claim a full refund with free of charge return handled by the brand.
Warranty
  • Choose Casper and get a 10-year warranty.
  • Comes with the standard 10-year Limited Warranty, similar to Casper.
 

Final Verdict

There is no such thing as the perfect mattress for all. It is really a matter of personal preference to decide which mattress suits you best, as there are several factors to consider, which have different significance for each individual.

As far as the two mattresses compared here, the clash does not reveal a winner in a blink of an eye. Sharing a similar trial period, shipping and warranty policy, the difference between Casper and the Tuft & Needle comes down to details. For instance, while both Casper and Tuft & Needle offer plenty of support, the first comes with a more hugging feel and sinking, whereas the Tuft & Needle is very supportive but firm.

In addition, the Casper sleeps cool, yet due to the fact that it sinks down more into the mattress, it might get hot at times, especially if you are a heavier sleeper. On the other hand, the Tuft & Needle sleeps really cool thanks to the special proprietary foam and heat-wicking technology infused in its construction. So, Tuft & Needle is probably the better of the two in terms of keeping you cool.

In addition, the Tuft & Needle offers better edge support and has minimal to none motion transfer, so it is best suited for couples and anyone who wants to use the bed for sitting, eating or intimate activities.

Both mattresses come with CertiPUR-US approved foams, which means they don’t emit toxic chemicals, however, Casper appears to have some distinct smell and slight off-gassing, whereas the Tuft & Needle is free of any smells and reportedly even smells pleasant when unpacked.

Overall, we think the Tuft & Needle wins over this battle, although you should be careful to review each of the specifics mentioned above to make your final decision based on your own needs.

Featured Reviews

Tuft & Needle Mattress
17,647 Reviews Analyzed
Medium Mattress & Box Spring Sets
4,624 Reviews Analyzed
Casper Mattresses
8,397 Reviews Analyzed
Latex Mattresses
414,639 Reviews Analyzed
Round Mattresses
586,313 Reviews Analyzed
Mattresses
1,284,157 Reviews Analyzed
Encased Coil Mattresses
288,498 Reviews Analyzed
Split King Mattresses
308,243 Reviews Analyzed
Reversible Mattresses
707,409 Reviews Analyzed

Related Posts